How to Build Guest Loyalty for Your Short-Term Rental

How to Build Guest Loyalty for Your Short-Term Rental

February 10, 20254 min read

In the competitive short-term rental (STR) market, guest loyalty is a powerful asset. Encouraging repeat bookings and word-of-mouth referrals not only reduces marketing costs but also creates a reliable revenue stream. This article outlines effective strategies to build guest loyalty and turn one-time visitors into lifelong advocates.

Why Guest Loyalty Matters

1. Increases Revenue

Repeat guests save you money on platform fees and marketing expenses.

2. Builds Predictable Income

Loyal guests provide consistent bookings, reducing the reliance on new customers.

3. Enhances Reputation

Satisfied returning guests often leave positive reviews and refer others.

4. Improves Efficiency

Repeat guests already understand your property, reducing onboarding time and effort.

Step 1: Create an Exceptional Guest Experience

1. Prioritize Cleanliness and Comfort

Ensure the property is spotless and equipped with high-quality amenities like comfortable beds, plush towels, and modern appliances.

2. Personalize Stays

Add thoughtful touches such as:

  • Welcome baskets with local products.

  • Handwritten thank-you notes.

  • Tailored recommendations based on guest preferences.

3. Be Responsive

Promptly address guest inquiries and resolve issues during their stay.

Step 2: Build Relationships With Guests

1. Communicate Regularly

Stay in touch with guests through:

  • Pre-arrival messages.

  • Mid-stay check-ins.

  • Post-stay thank-you notes.

2. Use Their Names

Address guests by name in messages to create a personal connection.

Example:
“Hi [Guest Name], we hope you’re enjoying your stay! Let us know if there’s anything we can assist you with.”

3. Remember Special Occasions

If guests mention a celebration, acknowledge it with a small gesture.

Example:
“Happy anniversary, [Guest Name]! We’ve left a bottle of champagne to help you celebrate.”

Step 3: Offer Loyalty Incentives

1. Create a Loyalty Program

Reward repeat guests with perks such as:

  • Discounts on future stays.

  • Complimentary upgrades.

  • Free nights after a certain number of bookings.

2. Provide Exclusive Offers

Offer special deals for direct bookings or off-peak stays.

Example:
“Book directly with us and enjoy 15% off your next stay!”

3. Surprise Guests With Bonuses

Send unexpected gifts or discounts to past guests to keep them engaged.

Step 4: Promote Direct Bookings

1. Build a Direct Booking Website

Make it easy for guests to book directly with you and avoid platform fees.

Tools:

  • Lodgify: Professional website creation for STRs.

  • Squarespace: Easy-to-use templates for direct booking pages.

2. Highlight Benefits

Emphasize why direct bookings are better for guests, such as lower rates and exclusive perks.

Step 5: Leverage Social Media

1. Stay Connected

Encourage guests to follow your STR on Instagram, Facebook, or Pinterest for updates and promotions.

2. Share User-Generated Content

Post photos or testimonials from guests (with their permission) to create a sense of community.

Example Post:
“Thank you, [Guest Name], for your amazing review! We can’t wait to host you again.”

Step 6: Collect and Act on Feedback

1. Send Post-Stay Surveys

Ask guests for feedback on their experience to identify areas for improvement.

Tools:

  • Google Forms: Simple survey creation.

  • Typeform: Interactive surveys for a better guest experience.

2. Implement Suggestions

Use guest feedback to make meaningful changes, then inform them of your updates.

Example:
“Thank you for your suggestion about adding blackout curtains. We’ve installed them in all bedrooms to ensure a more comfortable stay.”

Step 7: Recognize Repeat Guests

1. Welcome Them Back Warmly

Acknowledge returning guests with a personalized message or small gift.

Example:
“Welcome back, [Guest Name]! We’re thrilled to host you again. Enjoy a complimentary bottle of wine on us.”

2. Provide VIP Perks

Offer exclusive benefits like early check-ins, late check-outs, or priority booking during peak seasons.

Step 8: Create Memorable Experiences

1. Partner With Local Businesses

Collaborate with nearby restaurants, tour operators, or spas to offer discounts or packages.

2. Host Unique Events

Plan special activities for guests, such as wine tastings, cooking classes, or yoga sessions.

3. Showcase Local Attractions

Provide guides to hidden gems and must-see spots in your area.

Case Study: Building Loyalty in a Coastal STR

Scenario:
An STR owner in Santa Barbara wanted to increase repeat bookings among vacationing families.

Actions Taken:

  1. Offered a 10% discount for returning guests.

  2. Created a family-friendly welcome package with games, snacks, and beach toys.

  3. Sent personalized thank-you emails with exclusive offers for off-season stays.

Results:

  • Repeat bookings increased by 40% within a year.

  • Guests frequently mentioned the family-friendly touches in reviews.

  • Revenue during off-peak seasons improved by 25%.

Common Mistakes to Avoid

  1. Neglecting Guest Feedback: Failing to address suggestions can alienate loyal guests.

  2. Lacking Personalization: Generic interactions miss opportunities to create connections.

  3. Overpromising Perks: Be realistic about what you can consistently offer.

Tools to Build Guest Loyalty

  1. Lodgify: Create direct booking websites and manage guest relationships.

  2. Mailchimp: Automate email campaigns to stay connected with past guests.

  3. Typeform: Collect feedback with engaging surveys.

Cross-Link Opportunities

Explore related articles to enhance your STR strategy:

  • How to Attract Repeat Guests to Your STR

  • How to Enhance the Guest Experience for Your STR

  • How to Market Your STR on Social Media

Additional Resources

  1. Airbnb Host Blog: Insights on guest engagement.

  2. BiggerPockets STR Forum: Discussions on loyalty strategies for STRs.

  3. Hostfully Blog: Tips for building guest loyalty.

Conclusion

Building guest loyalty is about creating exceptional experiences, fostering relationships, and offering meaningful incentives. By focusing on these strategies, you can turn your short-term rental into a preferred destination for guests, driving repeat bookings and long-term success.

Back to Blog